Byfleet carer guided pen of dying grandmother to sign over £22,000, court hears

(Original story published on 16/05/18 on GetSurrey website - Original story)

A Byfleet carer guided the pen of a dying grandmother to get her to sign her over nearly all of the money in her bank account, a court has heard.

Rosie Stonard had returned from a holiday to her home in the Philippines when she helped seriously ill Marjorie Tomlinson write out a cheque to her worth £22,000 - leaving her with just over £1,000 in the bank.

The jury was told that the deathbed cheque - dated May 10, 2014 - was made when Walton resident Mrs Tomlinson was given just days to live after it was discovered she had cirrhosis of the liver when she was also treated at hospital for a broken wrist on her dominant hand.

Stonard was already written in Mrs Tomlinson’s will to be left £5,000, a further £10,000 in cash that was in a safe at her flat, and a Royal Crown Derby tea set.

She appeared in the dock at Guildford Crown Court on Monday (May 14) wearing a beige jacket, red top, and a blue scarf, as prosecutor Simon Shannon told a jury that Stonard felt she was entitled to the money as she had worked for Mrs Tomlinson for so long.

“Mrs Tomlinson was very very ill indeed and it was feared she may pass away at any moment,” he said.

“The prosecution case is that Rosie Stonard knew how much money was in Mrs Tomlinson’s account, a little over £23,000 at the time, and it is no coincidence the cheque was made out for £22,000. She wanted what she could get before Mrs Tomlinson passed away.”

The 50-year-old first began working as a cleaner for Mrs Tomlinson and her husband in 1998, but quickly became their carer when he suffered a stroke in 2000.

The trial is being held at Guildford Crown Court (Image: Steve Porter)
The jury of five men and seven women heard Mrs Tomlinson relied on Stonard a great deal following her husband’s death in 2012 and had previously lent the carer £20,000 to pay for an extension on her home.

“There is no doubt the two were close, and no doubt from time to time Mrs Tomlinson was generous to Rosie Stonard,” said Mr Shannon.

“It was agreed if the £20,000 was not repaid by the time Mrs Tomlinson died that money would be written off as well.”

Mrs Tomlinson’s suspicious granddaughter, Victoria Eugene, discovered the cheque when she became concerned about the state of her grandmother’s finances, the court heard.

A month before Mrs Tomlinson's died at the age of 87, Ms Eugene confronted the carer at her grandmother’s flat in October 2014, where Stonard told her that Mrs Tomlinson had insisted she give it to her and had written it out to her with a close family friend - a retired bank manager - present.

But Ms Eugene was unsatisfied with the carer’s explanation and reported her to the police, where Stonard told officers she had written out the cheque, but Mrs Tomlinson had signed it herself, the court heard.

However, the jury was told that a handwriting expert analysed the cheque and found it had not been signed by the pensioner at all.

“Rosie Stonard’s case now in fact is it wasn’t Marjorie Tomlinson that signed the cheque, not at least all by herself, and she had to assist by putting the pen in her hand and guiding her hand as she signed it because she acknowledged Mrs Tomlinson was very frail at the time,” said Mr Shannon.

Stonard, of Spence Avenue, denies one count of fraud.


Help for under-pressure local authority deputyship teams

(Originally published on 12/01/18 on localgov.co.uk)

The UK’s current demographic is providing near perfect conditions for a hot bed of financial abuse among vulnerable adults. There are currently 850,000 people in the UK living with dementia. In the next decade this could increase to over one million, and by 2051 to two million. Nearly 300,000 people are diagnosed with cancer every year - a significant number of whom will be unable to manage their finances at some point during their illness.
These frightening statistics do not marry up with the latest figures from the Office of the Public Guardian that showed only 626,165 lasting power of attorneys (LPO) were registered in 2016/2017.

Melanie Christodoulou, solicitor at FurleyPage, advises that this has resulted in an all time record number of people being subject to deputyship orders - orders issued by the Court of Protection appointing a deputy decision maker to manage the property and financial affairs of a person deemed not to have the capacity to do it themselves. This is where no LPA is in force and often no next of kin.

Figures for 2012/13 showed 45,804 deputyship orders. In 2016/17 that number has risen by 27% to 58,205 (source: Office of Public Guardian), with roughly one third of these supervised by deputyship teams within local authorities in England and Wales.
The process is often complicated and requires local authorities, their deputyship teams and internal solicitors to progress lengthy applications, supported by key evidence, and then step in to manage all the financial affairs in that person’s best interest. Local authorities often act as a last resort where there is no one else willing or able to take control of an individual’s affairs.

Not surprisingly local authorities report that costs to manage all of this escalate and current arrangements of fixed fees simply don’t cover the expenditure required to deliver the service. Fixed fees for professional deputies (both solicitors and local authorities) were raised in 2017 following many years of stagnation, even so the levels often do not reflect the amount of work undertaken in many cases.

This deputyship provision is very much needed, and as latest figures show demand is increasing at an unprecedented rate. Sadly the fees just do not cover the work undertaken in some cases.
As local authorities struggle with budget cuts, Paul Cruickshanks, Court of Protection Costs manager at bSquared Costs Law, recommends applying to the Court of Protection to have your costs assessed by the Senior Courts Cost Office (SCCO).

He says: ‘The subject of applying to the SCCO for costs to be assessed and maximising their return is a recurring topic for many deputyship teams. Rule 156 states that when P’s property and affairs are being dealt with, the costs are usually payable from P’s estate. I would always recommend requesting an option to have your costs assessed. The way in which costs are to be assessed can be more straightforward than one might expect, but authority from the Court of Protection is required. You still maintain the option of taking fixed costs.’

Mr Cruickshanks suggests the benefits of such an approach are twofold:

(1) In having your costs assessed, you are able to ensure that you are fairly remunerated for the important work you are undertaking.
(2) The SCCO has a duty to ensure that only costs reasonably incurred and proportionate in amount are payable by the protected party. By having your costs assessed, you can be sure that your client only pays what is fair and reasonable.

The role of deputyships, both independent and within local authorities, is vital to ensure vulnerable adults are not subjected to further financial abuse. Securing access to adequate funds to allow deputyship teams to provide this in-demand service is a direct reflection on how society looks after its most vulnerable.

David Lockwood is a former council corporate deputy and appointee, and now works for Finders International


Blue Badge changes - An update

Our friends at Ramsdens Solicitors report on Blue Badges and proposals to issue them to people with hidden disabilities.

https://www.ramsdens.co.uk/blog/blue-badges-hidden-disabilities


Panel Deputies - List updated

The Office of the Public Guardian has updated the list of Panel Deputies on their website.

The content is restricted to logged in users only. Please LOGIN or REGISTER to access the forums and additional webpages.

Court of Protection workload continues to rise

The latest Family Court statistics bulletin shows that the Court of Protection’s workload shows no signs of diminishing.

For example, 38,945 orders were made under the MCA last year an increase of nearly 50% on 2016. However, the report authors ascribe some of that increase to a “clearance of outstanding cases during the first quarter of 2017, and volumes have increased generally due to improved recording of orders made by  regional courts."

Over a third (40%) of the orders made related to the appointment of a deputy for property and affairs

The number of LPAs received also rose, with 180,210 received in the last quarter of the year up 18% on the equivalent quarter in 2016. Over the entire year, the increase was 28%, though there has been a drop in the two most recent quarters.

There were 2,552 Enduring Powers of Attorney (EPAs) in October to December 2017, down 5% on the same quarter in 2016. Annually, there was also a decrease of 7% in 2017 compared to 2016, continuing the long-term downward trend.

Original article from

http://www.courtofprotectionhub.uk/news/orders-made-under-the-mental-capacity-act-up-50-in-2017

Details of statistics can be found on the Government's website:

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/family-court-statistics-quarterly-october-to-december-2017?utm_source=099af3b3-8f54-4990-8d37-3f77cb23a7e3&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=govuk-notifications&utm_content=immediate


Making a Will - Law Commission consultation

Denzil Lush writes for the excellent 39 Essex Chambers newsletter on Substituted Judgment and Statutory Wills, read more by clicking on the link below:

 

http://www.39essex.com/content/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Mental-Capacity-Report-April-2018-Property-and-Affairs.pdf